October 4
See the original post here
Will there be a remake of Final Yamato following REBEL 3199?
I don’t think 3199 will be able to tie up every single loose end, so they’ll probably end up making a remake of The Final Chapter as well.
As for Captain Okita, they’ll likely have his personality, recreated via AI, placed into an android body manufactured by the Dezarium. Personally, though, I really hope they include the scene involving Dr. Sado’s misdiagnosis:
Dr. Sado: “Well, would you look at that, it was a misdiagnosis on my part! I suppose I ought to shave my head as an apology.”
Yuki: “Doctor, what exactly is left for you to shave?”
Dr. Sado: “Hmm…well, I suppose you’re right about that…”
Part of the charm of Yamato is fans pointing out things like, “If he was alive, why didn’t he let anyone know?” or “Doesn’t this mean the statue of Captain Okita on the Hill of Heroes was unnecessary?”
In that sense, I was genuinely disappointed by 2199. There were no instances of a massive fleet of 3,000 Gamilas ships going missing, nor was the third bridge completely destroyed over and over again! (Laugh)
Furthermore, the Dengil Empire was arguably the weakest enemy in Yamato history. their “hyper-radiation missiles” would have been ineffective against Gamilas people (who are resistant to radiation), and their city-fortress, Uruk, couldn’t withstand a Wave-Motion Gun blast, meaning even the Gamilas Empire could have defeated them.
They also had a surprisingly small number of warships.
And then there was that line, “Leave the women and children behind.” Even back when I was in the sixth grade, I remember thinking, “Wouldn’t that just lead to the extinction of the Dengil people?”
Still, I suppose it was perhaps better than Be Forever. If a remake of The Final Chapter were to be made, it would likely span 26 episodes again. Since it’s inconceivable for the final antagonist to be the weakest, the plot might involve Earthlings being saved by aliens, only for those very aliens to turn out to be the ultimate enemy, having seized advanced, unknown technology.
It would be incredibly exciting if, in 3199, Alphon survived, leading to a massive showdown: the Dengil fleet versus an allied force consisting of Yamato, the Galman-Garmillas Empire fleet (led by Dessler), the Bolar Federation fleet (led by Bemlarze), and the Dezarium fleet (led by Alphon). In this scenario, a Goruba could serve as a shield, holding off the Dengil attacks while the allies use a black hole cannon to annihilate the Dengil fleet, finally finishing off the city-fortress Uruk with a “Hyper Dessler Cannon”, a truly ultimate combo move!
October 11
See the original post here
On REBEL 3199 and Space Battleship Yamato √2199
Since I’ve run out of other topics for now, I’ll write a bit about Yamato √2199.
When I was in college, the Neon Genesis Evangelion TV series began airing. 26 years later, Evangelion: 3.0+1.0 Thrice Upon a Time was released in theaters.
That is the only film I’ve ever gone to see twice during its theatrical run. It wasn’t necessarily because it was exceptionally entertaining or moving. Rather, it was the profound sense of sentimentality I felt, realizing that an anime series from my youth had finally reached its conclusion all these years later. The final scene at Ube-Shinkawa Station, where Mari joins Shinji and the two head out into the outside world, nearly brought me to tears, though not so much because the direction itself was moving, but rather because it triggered a flood of memories from my own life over the past 26 years.
In short, Evangelion remains an enigmatic series. if someone were to ask me whether it stands as an enduring masterpiece in my life, I honestly wouldn’t know how to answer. That is why, even if it were announced that Director Anno was making a Yamato 2199 film, I simply couldn’t get excited about it.
While abstract, psychological themes feel right at home in Evangelion, they would feel completely out of place if brought into the world of Yamato.
Personally, I found Yamato 2199 itself to be rather lackluster. I had hoped to see the decisive battle on the Garmillas homeworld rendered with modern animation techniques. Instead, the conflict was reduced to Dessler acting as the sole villain. There was no climactic battle on the homeworld, nor did we see Kodai, who had harbored such intense hatred for Garmillas, shed a tear upon witnessing the planet transformed into a dead world.
Furthermore, the reunion between Kodai and his brother Mamoru was missing, as was the scene where they bid farewell to Mamoru and Starsha, who remained behind on Iscandar. These were the very elements that made Yamato so wonderful. seeing them all stripped away in the Yamato 2199 script left me with nothing but a sense of dissonance.
Even if a project included some of Director Anno’s signature, cryptic psychological themes, I believe that as long as those key, poignant moments were preserved, the result would at least be better than Yamato 2199. Everyone is entitled to their own perspective, and I have no intention of forcing my views on others, but for me, Yamato 2199 was an absolute failure.
At the same time, when a director of such stature takes on a remake, there’s always the risk that their own ego, a desire to “stamp their own personal style” onto the work, will take over, potentially leading to another disappointing result like Yamato 2199. I feel that the remake series has improved dramatically since 2205, so one could certainly argue that simply continuing this series would be enough.
According to online rumors, Yamato √2199 is set to be released after REBEL 3199 concludes, followed by a remake of The Final Chapter. In any case, all we can do is wait for further updates.
October 18
See the original post here
The Difference Between Watching Yamato as a Child and as an Adult
Since I don’t have any other topics to cover today, I’ll write about how my perception of Yamato has shifted between childhood and adulthood. I have a few thoughts on this, but today I’ll focus on the battle involving Mamoru Kodai near Pluto.
To begin with, though this was likely a narrative device to establish just how desperate Earth’s situation had become, the planet has already been contaminated by radiation from Planet Bombs, leaving humanity with only one year left to survive. At this point, the remnants of the Earth fleet, lacking even the capability for warp travel, undertake a long-range expedition, only to be intercepted by a Gamilas fleet that outclasses them in both numbers and mass.
Even if they had managed to annihilate the Gamilas fleet and destroy the Pluto base, it would have changed nothing. with no ships capable of warp travel, humanity would have had no means to escape Earth, leaving them still destined for total extinction a year later.
Looking back at the Battle of Pluto as an adult, and having since read extensively on military history, it strikes me as perhaps even more pointless than the final sortie of the battleship Yamato toward Okinawa during the closing stages of World War II.
Furthermore, Mamoru, defying the withdrawal order issued by Captain Okita (who, despite his title of “Captain,” effectively served as the fleet commander), chose on his own initiative to continue the attack against the Gamilas fleet. As a child, I thought, “Mamoru makes a fair point,” but viewing the scene now as an adult, I find his conduct entirely unacceptable for a military officer.
Not only did he disobey orders, but there is no indication that he sought or obtained the consent of his subordinates. His crew surely had families of their own. some might well have wondered, “Why are you ignoring the fleet commander’s orders to launch this assault? If you’re so determined to go, go alone! Don’t drag your subordinates down with you!”
Moreover, although Mamoru eventually returned to Earth, some of the surviving family members of the Yukikaze crew might have felt a deep sense of resentment: “You’re the one who ordered the charge, how dare you be the only one to survive? How could you possibly show your face back on Earth?”
Sanada later remarked, in essence, that Yukikaze sacrificed itself to cover Captain Okita’s withdrawal. However, I have my doubts about that. After all, Mamoru himself never said any such thing, and Sanada wasn’t even present at the scene.
It’s likely that Sanada heard about what happened to Mamoru from someone else, but perhaps he couldn’t bring himself to say that Mamoru had abandoned his only living relative, Kodai, to launch a reckless assault, ultimately dying in battle and taking his subordinates down with him. So, maybe he told a “kind lie”, claiming that Mamoru “died in battle while covering Captain Okita’s retreat.”
2199 corrected this point: the Battle of Pluto was reframed as a diversionary operation to allow Sasha to deliver the Wave-Motion Core, and Mamoru’s assault was given the purpose of covering Captain Okita’s retreat. It all makes perfect sense. I thought it was a clever fix for the rather loose, inconsistent writing of the original series. If the entire production had been handled with that same level of care, 2199 could have been a truly great work.
October 25
See the original post here
5 days until the release of Chapter 7
I’ve watched every installment, and I honestly think 3199 is the best of the lot.
It manages to incorporate original elements without straying from the core narrative of the classic series. It adds depth to characters like Dagon and those from the Bolar Federation, who were quite one-dimensional in the original, and provides a clear, logical motivation for why Alphon chose to side with the people of Earth.
Since the original Be Forever was only a little over two hours long, this version does more than just flesh out underdeveloped plot points. I truly believe it is the best anime I have seen in the 21st century. There is still Chapter 7 to go, but if the story concludes with Sasha and Alphon being saved, it might just become the greatest anime I’ve ever experienced, surpassing even the original works.
In the original, Starsha essentially tells her daughter, who had only lived for a single year, to die for the sake of Earth. Even as a third-grader, I remember thinking, “How could she say that to the daughter she sacrificed her own life to save?”
My theory is that the 17-year-old Sasha is a cyborg, possessing the memories of the 2-year-old Sasha, but with false memories implanted by Mother Dezarium. Regardless, I really hope that, in one way or another, Sasha is saved in 3199. Since this is an anime, I’m rooting for a satisfying conclusion where Sasha, the heroine, is rescued.
I also hope that Alphon, who saw through Mother Dezarium’s true nature and chose to fight against her, survives and goes on to become the leader of the Dezarium civilization once she’s gone. Then again, he’ll probably end up dying, won’t he…? Even when facing death, I hope they can reach the end of their lives feeling that it was good to have been born, that their existence brought them happiness.
In the original series, enemies other than the Gamilas Empire, such as the White Comet Empire, the Dark Nebula Empire, or the Dengil Empire, met their end with total destruction, and it is likely that not a single one of their citizens survived the conflict.
When the Garmillas homeworld was destroyed by the Dezarium in 2205 and 70% of the population perished, I, too, felt that the Dezarium deserved to be wiped out. Yet, the Garmillas Empire itself managed to overcome its hatred and reconcile with Earth and the Bolar Federation. That’s why I’ve come to believe that reconciliation with the moderate faction of Dezarium, those who broke free from Mother Dezarium’s brainwashing, is the right path. And, in truth, that is largely thanks to Alphon.
In the original series, a product of its time, supporting characters often lacked depth, with the focus remaining primarily on key figures like Kodai and Dessler. In 3199, however, supporting characters, such as Dagon, Boroze, Ram, Bemlarze, Alphon, and Isidore, are all portrayed in a truly compelling way. The story has been absolutely fantastic up through Chapter 6, so I truly hope Chapter 7 brings everything to a magnificent conclusion.
I’ll be heading to see Chapter 7 on October 30th, right after my night shift, and I plan to have a review posted shortly afterward, so look forward to it!
October 30
See the original post here
Chapter 7 Review: Some Quick Thoughts
To start, while there have been several remakes, I found 3199 to be the most enjoyable of them all. I thought 2205 was a perfect 100/100, but I believe 3199 has managed to surpass even that.
There was an unexpected surprise: an alliance with the Bolar Federation! Furthermore, characters who were previously little more than background figures: Dagon, Ram, Bemlarze, and Boroze, were transformed into truly compelling characters. These unforeseen developments made for a really entertaining experience for fans.
I had made some predictions about Chapter 7, and I was mostly correct regarding Sasha. I had guessed that the 17-year-old Sasha was created based on the 2-year-old version, and that the 2-year-old Sasha would survive, which turned out to be the case.
Also, I had assumed that the use of “phase energy” had made it impossible for the Dezarians to survive in their original biological bodies, forcing them to become cyborgs, though I hadn’t anticipated that the entire Dezarian race had already been wiped out. I initially thought the planet Iscandar was captured so that the Cosmo Reverse could restore the Dezarian homeworld to its original state, but according to Mother Dezarium, the goal was actually “to reach heaven.” It wasn’t explicitly explained what this “heaven” is, but I imagine that will be revealed in the upcoming remake of Final Yamato.
Still, it’s quite bizarre that Mother Dezarium, an AI, would harbor a desire to reach heaven or aspire for her kind to become the sole “chosen” race in the entire universe, especially since the actual Dezarium people have already gone extinct. To that end, she even created the Dezarium beings as mere terminals and went as far as deceiving the people of Earth just to get her hands on a “pure” Wave-Motion Core. Since even the Dezariums couldn’t manufacture a pure Wave-Motion Core themselves, it goes to show just how incredibly advanced Iscandar’s scientific capabilities must have been.
I expected Alphon to die, but I was surprised when the surviving Dezarians, instead of forming a friendly government with Earth and coexisting, much like the Garmillans, lost their phase energy and simply ceased to exist. It was truly heartbreaking when Maxim and Fleur vanished.
Also, the final scene where Bemlarze is working in the fields alongside Ram gave me a good laugh! To top it off, Darya was watching them on a monitor and laughing, too. I was genuinely surprised to see that kind of expression from her. That was easily my favorite part of the ending.